Join Our Mailing List:

Ticket Exchange How-To

If you can't make it to a show, never fear! One of the many benefits of being a subscriber is our Subscriber Ticket Exchange. And it's done in two easy steps!

  1. Call the box office at 973-334-9320 or email us at and leave us a message saying you're doing an exchange. (Make sure you also leave your name and show date you're changing from and the new date you want!)
  2. Mail your tickets to:

    Barn Theatre
    P.O. Box 102
    Montville NJ 07045
    Attn: Box Office - Ticket Exchange
- or -
  1. Stop by the box office during office hours - Saturdays between 4-7 - and we can handle the exchange right there!


  1. We must receive your exchange request at least 24 hours prior to your scheduled performance.
  2. We cannot exchange tickets on the day of your performance or after your performance has passed.
  3. We cannot exchange tickets from one play to another.
  4. If you change your membership ticket from a matinee to an evening performance, you will be subject to a $4 per ticket surcharge.

Please be aware that exchanges are subject to availability, but we will make every effort to provide you with comparable seats.